Science Of Freedom Workbook
Text: "The Philosophy of Freedom" by Rudolf Steiner
Topic 2.4 Chapter 2 The Fundamental Desire For Knowledge
2.4 Idealism
Naturalism
The most extreme Spiritualist or, better said, Idealist, is Johann Gottlieb Fichte. He attempts to derive the whole world structure from the “Ego.”
Theism
What he has actually accomplished is a magnificent thought-picture of the world without any content of experience.
Intuitionism
As little as it is possible for the Materialist to do away with the Mind, just as little is it possible for the Idealist to do away with the external world.
Worldview Of Idealism
"The world has no real meaning unless there is within it a progressive tendency, unless from this external world something can emerge towards which the human soul can direct itself, independently of the world."
"life has meaning only if ideas work through it and give it purpose."
"takes everything as a vehicle for the ideas that permeate the world-process."
"Beautiful and grand and glorious things have been brought forward on behalf of Idealism."
"the point is to show that the world would be purposeless and meaningless if ideas were only human inventions and were not rooted in the world-process."
Rudolf Steiner, Human And Cosmic Thought lectures
The description of Idealism in the following quote carries profound implications about the nature of reality, purpose, and the human soul's relationship with the world:
"The world has no real meaning unless there is within it a progressive tendency, unless from this external world something can emerge towards which the human soul can direct itself, independently of the world." Rudolf Steiner, Human And Cosmic Thought lectures
-
Progressive Tendency: The phrase "progressive tendency" implies that the world should be moving forward, evolving, or advancing in some way. In the context of Idealism, this progression isn't just technological or societal but is deeply philosophical and spiritual. The world, from this perspective, isn't just a series of random events but has a direction, a purpose, or an underlying drive towards some kind of betterment or realization.
-
Something Can Emerge: The quote suggests that out of this ever-progressing world, there are unique phenomena, insights, or realizations that can arise. These emergent properties aren't just ordinary events but are significant in guiding the human soul.
-
Directing the Human Soul: These emergent aspects of the world serve as points of inspiration, direction, or guidance for the human soul. It's like the North Star for sailors - even though the sailors move independently of the star, the star provides direction.
-
Independently of the World: The final part of the quote is particularly crucial. It implies that while these emergent properties guide the human soul, the direction the soul takes is independent of the world. It's a paradoxical relationship. The world provides the signposts, but the journey the soul undertakes, the meanings it constructs, and the direction it chooses, are determined from within, not just by external factors.
For more on this form of Idealism see 5. A TALE OF TWO IDEALISMS in this module. This description of Idealism captures a world that is not stagnant but is dynamically moving forward. Within this dynamic world are emergent phenomena that the human soul can use for guidance. However, the soul's journey, while informed by the world, is ultimately a deeply personal and internal one. The soul finds its direction not just by looking outside but by aligning its inner compass with the broader progression of the world.
"The most extreme Spiritualist or, better said, Idealist, is Johann Gottlieb Fichte. He attempts to derive the whole world structure from the 'Ego.' "
"Deriving the World from the Ego" emphasizes the peak of idealistic thought, where the entire structure of the world and everything in it is believed to emanate from one's inner sense of self, or 'Ego'. In this view, the self, or the conscious mind, is the foundation from which all understanding of the world is built. It's a perspective that places immense power on the subjective reality, suggesting that everything external is a projection or manifestation of the internal 'Ego'.
"What he has actually accomplished is a magnificent thought-picture of the world without any content of experience."
Despite constructing an intricate and detailed internal model of the world, this approach lacks the richness and nuance that comes from actual experiential interactions with the world. In essence, by relying solely on the internal world of ideas and not grounding them in experiential reality, the resulting picture, while magnificent, lacks depth and dimension. It's like a painting that captures the semblance of a scene but lacks the lived experience of being in that scene.
"As little as it is possible for the Materialist to do away with the Mind, just as little is it possible for the Idealist to do away with the external world."
While the materialist finds it impossible to deny the existence and influence of the mind, the idealist too cannot fully dismiss the external world. This quote underscores the interconnectedness of the internal world of thought and the external world of material existence. It suggests that, just as materialists can't ignore the influence of the mind, idealists cannot completely turn away from the external world's influence on their internal perceptions and beliefs.
Idealism, as portrayed in these quotes, emphasizes the primacy of the internal world of thoughts and ideas. However, it also recognizes that this internal realm is not isolated but is continually interacting with and influenced by the external world. The true challenge is to strike a balance between the two, recognizing the importance of both the inner 'Ego' and the tangible experiences of the external world.
MODULE 2.4 Idealism
□ STEP 2.4 From one-sided idealism focused on the world of ideas and ideals, to discerning the separation caused by distancing from external world experience.
1. INTRODUCTION
Idealists look for ideals to give life purpose. They dwell in realms of possibilities, often focusing intently on the conceptual. This focus on the world of ideas, while it offers deep insights and visionary thinking, can sometimes remain tethered only to the ethereal plane, neglecting the tangible world that surrounds us. This is the stage of one-sided idealism.
One-sided idealism revels in its dreamlike explorations, crafting an intricate tapestry of thoughts and ideals. However, without anchoring these ideas in the real-world experiences, they can float adrift. They may lose relevance to the practical necessities of daily life, resulting in decisions that, while intellectually sound, may falter when applied. For instance, an individual deeply engrossed in such idealism might conceive a world of perfect harmony but struggle with the simple intricacies of daily interactions or be unprepared for the ebbs and flows of real-life challenges. Their beliefs, while noble, might leave them unanchored in the face of adversity, leading to a certain fragility of spirit.
On a societal scale, policies born from pure idealism, untempered by the realities of people's lived experiences, can become abstract exercises, failing to address the genuine needs of the population. Such policies, while appearing perfect on paper, might be ill-suited to the complexities of societal dynamics. Moreover, an over-reliance on idealism can also make societies susceptible to rigid dogmatic structures, leading to resistance against new ideas or alternative viewpoints. The potential pitfalls of a society too deeply entrenched in ungrounded idealistic ideology become evident in these scenarios.
Recognizing the chasm between the world of ideas and tangible experiences becomes imperative. It's here that "guided curiosity" is important. By being aware of this separation, individuals can start to bridge the gap between their lofty ideals and the world they inhabit. They can begin to ask probing questions, re-evaluate their understanding, and seek ways to meld their idealistic visions with the world's pragmatic demands. In doing so, they not only enrich their personal worldview but also contribute to a society that values both the dream and the reality, ensuring that neither remains isolated from the other.
Worldview of Idealism: Emphasizes the central role of ideas and ideals grasped from the inner self by intuition and inspiration, often prioritizing them over world experience.
World of Ideas and Ideals: A realm of abstract concepts, beliefs, and ideals that exists independently of tangible, empirical experiences.
Distancing From External World of Experience: The tendency to detach or disengage from tangible, real-world interactions and events, focusing predominantly on abstract thought and internal contemplation, often at the expense of practical understanding and engagement with the external world.
Guided Curiosity
One-sided Idealism creates an imbalance, where the conceptual doesn't always align with the practical, leading to potential pitfalls in understanding and interpretation. 'Guided curiosity' is concerned with the limitations of a one-sided perspective. The essence of 'guided curiosity' lies in a harmonious interplay between the world of ideas and the world of experiential realities. It is a journey of understanding propelled by a balance between the imaginative capacity of the mind and the grounded nature of real-world experiences. For example:
Imagine a philosopher who has spent years developing a detailed theory about the ideal methods of agriculture, solely based on his readings and internal contemplations. He believes his methods are groundbreaking. However, when he presents them to a farmer—the person in touch with the soil, the weather patterns, and the real challenges of agriculture—the farmer finds these methods impractical. Here, the philosopher's distancing from the external world of experience hinders the real-world applicability of his ideas.
A tech visionary conceptualizes an advanced gadget believing it to be the next big thing. It's based on his idea of what the world needs. However, when launched, users find it complicated and non-intuitive. The product, born from pure idealism, lacked insights from real-world user experience.
'Guided curiosity' would encourage the philosopher to spend time on a farm and the tech visionary to engage with potential users during the design phase. By discerning the separation, they can better guide their curiosity to bridge the gap between the conceptual and the practical, ensuring their ideas find meaningful resonance in the real world.
2. LIFE EXAMPLES
Scenario: Urban Gardener
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: A city dweller reads extensively about self-sustaining gardens, visualizing a perfect ecosystem where plants and animals thrive in harmony. In their mind, they've envisioned the layout, chosen the plants, and even imagined the symphony of birds that would frequent this garden.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: The individual finally secures a small plot to make this dream a reality. However, the soil isn't as fertile as they thought, local birds show no interest, and pests are rampant. Their idealized garden, while perfect in theory, didn’t account for the challenges and unpredictable nature of actual gardening.
Scenario: Environmental Activist
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: An individual, deeply moved by documentaries on climate change, envisions a world where people can reverse the damage done to the planet. They believe if everyone just adopted sustainable practices, we could easily save the Earth.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: Upon joining a local environmental group, they confront the complex and often demoralizing realities of bureaucracy, corporate resistance, and questionable environmental science. They find that affecting real change is a far more labyrinthine task than their initial idealistic vision allowed for.
Scenario: Commune Dreamer
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: A city worker, tired of the capitalist grind, dreams of a commune where everyone shares tasks, lives off the land, and participates in nightly group meditation and discussions. They envision harmony, mutual understanding, and a seamless blend of work and leisure.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: When they finally join a commune, they find clashing personalities, disagreements over shared responsibilities, and the hard physical labor of farming. The day-to-day reality is far from the peace and harmony they had idealized.
Scenario: Benevolent Giver
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: A kind-hearted individual decides to dedicate weekends to helping the less fortunate. He imagines grateful smiles, transformative moments, and building lasting connections with those he aids, turning their lives around with his support.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: While volunteering, he encounters individuals who react with skepticism or indifference. Some of the disadvantaged are wary of strangers, others are resentful of the volunteers "privilege", leaving little room for gratitude. The individual learns that altruism is more complex than simply giving and receiving thanks.
Scenario: Aspiring Entrepreneur
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: An individual with big dreams of starting a successful tech company pours over success stories, TED Talks, and inspirational quotes daily. They believe that with the right idea, hard work, and a little bit of luck, they'll change the world and become the next big name in Silicon Valley.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: After diving in, they encounter a slew of unexpected challenges: unreliable co-founders, complex legal hurdles, fierce competition, and technical setbacks. They realize that the romanticized world of startups is far more complicated and less glamorous than the vision they'd held so dearly.
Scenario: Advancing The Unqualified
Stage 1 - Worldview Of Idealism: A budding entrepreneur believes in the idea of surrounding herself with friends in her startup, valuing trust and camaraderie over credentials. She imagines an office where work feels like an extension of friendly gatherings, filled with laughter and shared memories.
Stage 2 - Lack World Experience: After hiring several close friends who were under qualified, she faces challenges. Some friends lack the necessary skills, leading to missed deadlines. Others struggle to separate personal feelings from professional feedback. Other employees become resentful of the unearned merit hiring. The initial joy of working with friends becomes clouded by the complexities of maintaining professionalism while preserving personal relationships.
3. THE PHILOSOPHY OF FREEDOM TOPIC 2.4 QUOTE
"He attempts to derive the whole world structure from the “Ego.” What he has actually accomplished is a magnificent thought-picture of the world without any content of experience."
The quote challenges the notion of deriving an entire understanding or structure of the world based solely on introspection or one's internal thoughts, represented here by the term "Ego." To better grasp this, consider a book enthusiast who has read countless travel novels about Paris, creating a vivid and detailed mental image of the city's architecture, culture, and ambiance. Idealization can add another layer. When we idealize, we create an enhanced, often oversimplified image or concept of something, based on what we believe or wish it to be, rather than its nuanced reality.
Our book enthusiast idealizes Paris as a perfect city where romance blossoms on every corner, and every croissant tastes heavenly. They may feel they understand Paris completely. However, this intellectual understanding, while intricate, lacks the multi-sensory experience of actually walking the streets of Paris, tasting its cuisine, or interacting with its residents. Upon visiting, they might be disappointed by any imperfection, such as a rainy day or a less than perfect meal. Their idealized image could overshadow the real charm and multifaceted nature of the city.
Similarly, someone might have a deep intellectual understanding of love from books, songs, and movies. They could construct a comprehensive idea of what love should feel like, look like, and how it should evolve. Someone who has an idealized concept of love might expect it to always be like the movies – full of grand gestures, with no conflicts, and always ending in a "happily ever after." Yet, without ever having been in love or experienced the roller-coaster of emotions it brings, that understanding remains somewhat hollow or two-dimensional. Their first disagreement with a partner might then be seen as a sign of incompatibility, rather than a natural aspect of relationships.
In these scenarios, the individuals are deriving their understanding of the world from an "Ego" that is not only introspective but also colored by idealized notions. Their magnificent thought-pictures of the world, thus, not only lack content of experience but might also be misaligned from the diverse realities of life. The danger of idealization, especially when combined with lack of experience, is that it can lead to disillusionment. The world rarely conforms to our idealized images of it. By engaging deeply with the world and gaining varied experiences, one can counterbalance the tendencies of idealization and achieve a more holistic, enriched understanding.
4. REFLECTION QUESTIONS FOR THE PRACTICE OF PURE THINKING
Objective: Experience the joy of soaring into the realm of concepts.
How does an idealistic perspective influence our motivations, aspirations, and actions in our day-to-day life? How do we know whether our idealistic vision is progressive or actually regressive? Do you think the world is inherently meaningful and progressing, or is this something humans construct? Can you identify an ideal "progressive tendency" in your own life or in society at large?
5. A TALE OF TWO IDEALISMS
Introduction
The following narrative juxtaposes two distinct philosophies of Idealism as they manifest in the real world, exploring what happens when high-reaching ideals confront the grit and complexity of human existence. On one side, we have an approach mirroring Johann Gottlieb Fichte's topic 2.4 extreme Idealism. In this view, the "Ego" or self serves as the fountainhead from which an entire vision of the world flows. It’s an idealism crafted from the mind, beautiful in its purity but detached from the intricate realities of human behavior and societal structures.
On the other side stands Rudolf Steiner's expression of Idealism described in his Human And Cosmic Thought lectures, "The world has no real meaning unless there is within it a progressive tendency, unless from this external world something can emerge towards which the human soul can direct itself, independently of the world." This version acknowledges the fallibilities and imperfections of the world, yet seeks the "progressive tendencies" within these complexities. It recognizes that the external world can guide the human soul towards something greater, but ultimately leaves the soul to journey independently. For more on this form of Idealism see the Worldview Of Idealism in this module.
Our story follows Alex, a young man who traverses the chasm between these two philosophies in his quest to address homelessness. He starts with a vision almost utopian in its extremity, then journeys towards a more nuanced, progressive form of idealism. Through Alex's experiences, we delve into the challenges, triumphs, and sobering lessons gleaned from the clash and reconciliation of these contrasting idealistic worldviews.
From Utopia to Reality: A Tale of Two Idealisms
Alex looked out over the university conference room, his eyes glowing with the fire of conviction. His presentation showcased his dream: The Homeless Support Initiative. Mini-homes, communal gardens, art therapy; a real-life utopia in a city park where all would be welcome. The room burst into applause, and Alex felt like he was floating.
Months later, the mini-home village became a reality. The tiny houses looked almost magical under the glow of solar lights, the common area inviting with its public art installations. Alex walked through the rows, his heart swelling. However, as the days went by, the shine started to fade. Lucy turned her mini-home into a drug den, and David roamed the village with increasing aggression. The community began to fracture. Alex felt his utopia crumbling in slow motion but was paralyzed by the sheer force of its decay.
Despite his disillusionment, Alex noticed a glimmer of success: a few residents had thrived by maintaining personal garden plots. Those who cared for their plots were thriving. Not only did they meet their produce needs but a surplus was sold each week at a farmers market. Could the system be modified to encourage this kind of personal responsibility? Alex is inspired to try a new approach. With renewed vigor, Alex launched The Homeless Independence Initiative. The new program still provided the basics, but it added structure: vocational training, mental health services, and strict rules for community participation, starting with the garden plots.
Sarah, once listless and indifferent, seemed to come alive. She attended the vocational workshops and tended to her garden with religious devotion. A few months later, she found a job and moved out into permanent housing. Witnessing her transformation, Alex was filled with joy. However, Lucy found the new expectations suffocating. She left in the middle of the night, and David, after a sincere but failed attempt to stick to the program, simply disappeared. Alex felt each departure like a body blow, but he also recognized that his new approach couldn't be all things to all people.
Back in the same conference room, but with a more mature demeanor, Alex spoke of his journey. He compared the "Extreme Idealism" of his original vision to the "Progressive Idealism" he had later embraced. His voice wavered as he admitted to his mistakes, but his eyes shone brighter when he spoke of those who'd moved on to better lives.
Walking through the village that evening, Alex stopped at the empty plot that had once been Sarah’s. He thought about how the plot had become a proving ground, a way for her to regain her self-respect and agency. It wasn't utopia, but it was real, and sometimes reality was enough. In that moment, Alex felt a profound sense of peace. His idealism was no longer an abstract concept but a living, breathing entity, as flawed and as beautiful as the people it aimed to serve.
6. PRACTICAL APPLICATION OF IDEALISM
Objective: Adopt an individualistic attitude aligned with principles of freedom.
- Create an "Idealism Board": Much like a vision board, an "Idealism Board" is a physical or digital space where you can pin ideas, quotes, images, and anything else that represents your ideals. This can be inspirational quotes, images of people who embody your ideals, symbols, etc.
- Idealistic Daydreaming: Allocate time for what may be termed "idealistic daydreaming" where you let your mind wander to envision the best possible scenarios for different aspects of life—whether it's personal relationships, societal systems, or self-improvement, no matter how unrealistic they may seem.
- The S.M.A.R.T Idealist: Use the S.M.A.R.T (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) goal-setting framework to create tangible steps that align with your ideals.
Steps:
1. Break down your idealistic vision into smaller, specific goals.
2. Make sure these goals are measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound.
3. Track your progress and adjust as needed, ensuring that your ideals are always in conversation with reality.
7. CLOSING THOUGHTS
The theme of guided curiosity is about directing one's innate sense of wonder toward meaningful pursuits, and it resonates profoundly with the tenets of idealism. Through idealism, you're not just curious about the world as it is but also about the world as it could be. This form of guided curiosity illuminates the path forward, suggesting not only what to learn but also why to learn it.
For the individual, embracing idealism can lead to a more enriching life. The dream of an ideal world serves as an emotional and psychological beacon, inspiring action and providing a sense of purpose. This idealistic vision can make choices clearer, as individuals are guided by a consistent set of values or objectives. And it's not just about a rosy outlook; idealism can instill a type of optimism that not only elevates one's mood but also enhances resilience, enabling people to bounce back from setbacks because they're driven by a purpose larger than themselves.
As for society, the impact of idealism is transformative. When people dare to imagine a better world, they're also taking the first steps toward innovation. This spirit of "what could be" doesn't just drive technological advancements; it creates a fertile ground for reimagining social structures, laws, and community norms. Take movements for social change, for example. They often begin with a single idealistic vision—perhaps one of privacy rights, free speech, or educational choice—and this vision gathers momentum, inspiring individual action that can lead to tangible improvements. Idealists often step into roles of leadership, not because they seek power, but because their genuine enthusiasm and belief in a better world are infectious, inspiring others.
However, it's crucial to marry this idealism with experience, to keep it tethered to the real world. Idealism that's too far removed from the realities of human existence can result in disillusionment or projects that fail to take root. The balance lies in using idealism as the compass for our guided curiosity while letting our experiences in the actual world inform how we navigate the challenges along the way. Idealism is not an escape from the world but an engagement with it at its highest potential.
