|
John Dewey and Rudolf Steiner on Education
| What would John Dewey and Rudolf Steiner have said to one another about education?
Although they were contemporaries, they never met. Jacque Ensign (Department of Education Studies, University of Virginia) has concocted a lively fictional conversation about education between John Dewey and Rudolf Steiner here, courtesy of the ever-surprising online anthroposophical journal from Argentina, The Southern Review.
Jacque Ensign writes:
John Dewey and Rudolf Steiner were contemporaries who each launched radical worldwide educational approaches: Progressivism and Waldorf schools. Each wrote and spoke about his philosophy and formulated concrete ways to put it into practice in schools. Steiner wrote over sixty books and 6,000 essays, lectures, and articles. Dewey was such a prolific writer that whole books have been published as Dewey bibliographies. In many respects, Dewey and Steiner differed greatly in their philosophies and methods, but they also shared some common premises about education. With many professional parents sending their children to Waldorf schools, it is time to look at Waldorf education from a Deweyan perspective. Read on…
|
- John Ralph's journal
- 1 comment
- 256 reads
Handbook of all Rudolf Steiner’s lectures and books in German
German readers may not realize that there is an indexed handbook by Christian Karl in PDF format (65MB) covering all Rudolf Steiner’s lectures and books.
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 200 reads
Empathic Civilisation
How many anthroposophical tenets can you identify, that the speaker Jeremy Rifkin seems to accept as fact, in this animated video from the Royal Society of Arts?
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 218 reads
Introspection and the Phases of Life
- John Ralph's journal
- 1 comment
- Read more
- 199 reads
Hermann Hesse in The Southern Cross Review
In its tenth anniversary issue The Southern Cross Review has some beautiful poems by Hermann Hesse among other contributions that are worth a look.
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 284 reads
Picture from Aberdeen PoF Study Group
Picture from Aberdeen PoF Study Group - see the report here.
- 3 comments
- Read more
- 427 reads
Sound Spiritual Experience (ALT005)
Is self-knowledge about our true self --beyond the experience of our self in ordinary everyday life-- possible? |
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 355 reads
One individual’s knowing is another’s belief (ALT004)
Anthroposophical Leading Thought (4)
- John Ralph's journal
- 3 comments
- Read more
- 553 reads
Mental Fight by Ben Okri
I would like to share these inspiring words from the author and poet, Ben Okri.
Mental Fight (selected extracts)
By Ben Okri
- John Ralph's journal
- 4 comments
- Read more
- 1015 reads
Rudolf Steiner Archive offline
Some of you will have noticed that the Rudolf Steiner Archive is offline at the moment. I have received the following explanation and request for support.
Please consider making a donation to the http://www.rsarchive.org/. The site is down, the server has been damaged by a power surge. James Stewart is struggling financially to replace it. If you live in the US donations are tax deductable. They can be sent to The e.Lib, Inc. P.O. Box 293 Fremont, MI 49412-0293 US or made through Paypal to The e.Lib. Thank you.
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 554 reads
A Michaelmas Thought
As a contribution to this festival day, I offer a reminder of the mighty task before us: to hold the wellbeing of the world (and its environment) within our self-aware activity.
Mother Nature, your sustaining presence
I bear deep within my will
And my will’s fiery vigour
Can temper my impulsive mind,
Evoking self-awareness
To hold me wholly in me.
-- Rudolf Steiner, Calendar of the Soul: 26 (trans. JR)--end
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 453 reads
The Lucifer Effect - Beyond Good and Evil

I'm reading a recent book called "The Lucifer Effect" by Philip Zimbardo, who carried out a well-known experiment called the "Stanford Prison Experiment" in the early 1970s. See http://www.zimbardo.com/current.html for more details. To quote from that site:
The Lucifer Effect raises a fundamental question about the nature of human nature: How is it possible for ordinary, average, even good people to become perpetrators of evil? In trying to understand unusual, weird or aberrant behavior, we often err in focusing exclusively on the inner determinants of genes, personality and character, as we also tend to ignore what may be the critical catalyst for behavior change in the external Situation or in the System that creates and maintains such situations.
After narrating his experiences during the running of the Stanford Prison Experiment, he spends a lot of time discussing its connection to other situations including the recent well-publicised Abu Ghraib prison abuses.
I find it interesting that this book reflects the perspective of an academic of long experience in experimental psychology with no interest in or familarity with Anthroposophy - he seems familiar with mainstream Christian and English literature, twentieth century existentialism etc. but if you look at the index you will find no reference to Jung or Freud, let alone Steiner or Goethe. Literary quotes are usually taken from John Milton (of all people), Dante or twentieth century authors. Yet I think he comes to a very similar standpoint to Steiner in the Philosophy of Freedom - that both external and internal determinants make us unfree, make us "evil" or potentially "evil". And it may be that someone who appears "good" could just as well become "evil" if the right external conditions were brought to bear.
Again, Friedrich Nietzsche, who had so much to say on the topic of so-called Good and Evil, and whose spiritual striving Steiner felt so close to in one sense (see for example "Friedrich Nietzsche, Fighter for Freedom" http://wn.rsarchive.org/Books/GA005/English/GC1985/GA005_index.html for more details), is not even mentioned. But I believe I can almost hear things in line with something of the spirit of Nietzsche's "Beyond Good and Evil", for example, in some of what is said in the Zimbardo book.
I haven't finished the book properly yet (it's quite long) but Zimbardo does finish on a positive note that again seems to be to be in fundamental agreement with the tone of all of Steiner's work and especially the Philosophy of Freedom - the last chapter is entitled "Resisting Situational Influences and Celebrating Heroism". And I think Nietzsche's Zarathustra might breath a sigh of relief also that others are striving towards his mountaintop.
Again, all this leads me to think along with others here on this website that it is the Philosophy of Freedom that is still the most contemporary of Steiner's works. While personally I find all of Steiner's works wonderful, I can understand that someone like Prof. Zimbardo, with all of his own gathered wisdom and life experience and with his prominent position in the mainstream psychological community, would be unlikely to find much of interest in "Occult Science", for example, let alone be able to make reference to it in a work like "The Lucifer Effect" (despite the remarkable synchronicity of the title!). --end
- Tim Bourke's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 449 reads
Anthroposophical and Transpersonal Worldviews by Robert McDermott
An interesting essay on Anthroposophical and Transpersonal Worldviews by Robert McDermott is available in the latest Southern Cross Review.
Robert writes:
“I am often accused by my East Coast friends of having “gone Californian,” and by my San Francisco Bay Area friends of being still “very East Coast.” Neither characterization is intended as a compliment. Reference points for New York academic life tend to be the canonical tradition from Socrates to Godimer whereas comparable reference points for the Bay Area transpersonal community tend to be Asian spiritual teachers; meditation techniques; goddess, shamanic and Jungian symbols; astrological archetypes and Enneagram points. When I appear to my East Coast friends as too Californian, it is because of my delight in the varieties of spirit manifest in transpersonal psychologists and artists, in the eighty dharma centers in the Bay Area, sacred medicine researchers, teachers of biography, eco-feminists, multi-traditional mystics, organizational experts, and astrologers. Anthroposophy is not ordinarily listed in such a catalogue, and there are excellent reasons why it should not be, as well as reasons why it should be hence this essay." more...
- John Ralph's journal
- 8 comments
- Read more
- 603 reads
Do I know you, Rudolf Steiner? (ALT003)
Tim recently posted this extract from Occult Science – an Outline: Chapter 1.
In the spirit and true sense of the word, no real scientist will be able to find a contradiction between his science built upon the facts of the sense world and the method by which the supersensible world is investigated. The scientist makes use of certain instruments and methods. He produces his instruments by transforming what “nature” offers him. The supersensible method of knowledge also makes use of an instrument. This instrument is man himself. This instrument, too, must first be made ready for higher research. The capacities and forces given to man by nature, without his assistance, must be transformed into higher capacities and powers. Man is thereby able to make himself the instrument for research in the supersensible world.
http://wn.rsarchive.org/Books/GA013/English/AP1972/GA013_c01.html
I have come to ‘know’ Rudolf Steiner from reading his writings and lectures that have been translated into English. I have never met him face to face although I have seen photographs. He died before I was born. Do I really have any knowledge of the good doctor?
- John Ralph's journal
- 4 comments
- Read more
- 451 reads
Finding the Aesthetic of Sophia as a Response to Terrorism and Counter Terrorism in the World
- John Ralph's journal
- 7 comments
- Read more
- 637 reads
Spirit Knowledge (ALT002)
How can we best communicate spiritual truths?
- John Ralph's journal
- 11 comments
- Read more
- 667 reads
Independent Newspaper UK: Tibet Situation with Anthroposophical Context
- John Ralph's journal
- 4 comments
- Read more
- 586 reads
A Path from the Heart (ALT001)
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 645 reads
A Study on the Etheric Heart
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 770 reads
Goethe's Fairy Tale
- John Ralph's journal
- 1 comment
- Read more
- 1573 reads
Ubuntu
Ubuntu (pronounced "oo-BOON-too") is a traditional African idea that means rather more than humanity toward others and I am because you are also the belief in a universal bond of sharing that connects all humanity. |
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 550 reads
Anthroposophia
Another new conversation group has been inaugurated on the PoF website: Anthroposophia.
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 436 reads
Foundation Stone Group
Subscribers to this group may be interested in the new new conversation group on this site on the Foundation Stone Meditation.
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 423 reads
Communicating Anthroposophy
Today I was asked to contribute to a conversation in a couple of weeks on the theme How can anthroposophy be effectively communicated to non-anthroposophists? |
- John Ralph's journal
- 7 comments
- Read more
- 758 reads
Essentials of Anthroposophy
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 502 reads
What distinguishes Anthroposophy?
What marks it out as distinctive, and why? |
- John Ralph's journal
- 11 comments
- Read more
- 745 reads
New Adult Learning Movement
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 455 reads
Will to Think
- John Ralph's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 533 reads
Ideals and Archetypes
- John Ralph's journal
- 34 comments
- Read more
- 777 reads
Emancipation of the World
When we see artistic expressions of the Archangel Michael, we are reminded in so many ways that here be dragons.
- John Ralph's journal
- 3 comments
- Read more
- 510 reads
Victory of St Michael, Coventry
St Michael and the Dragon by Durer
World Participation
There are many ways in which we participate in world events, both actively and passively.
- John Ralph's journal
- 22 comments
- Read more
- 712 reads
Unfamiliar voices in familiar territory
I found two articles that I am sure will interest students of living thinking.
- John Ralph's journal
- 1 comment
- Read more
- 475 reads
The Humility of the Teacher
On being a teacher...
- Tim Bourke's journal
- 1 comment
- Read more
- 473 reads
Is Motion Real?
John and Carl have started an interesting discussion on the nature of movement, is it only an illusion, or are objects really in motion as they appear to be. Here are some thoughts on movemen
- Tim Bourke's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 454 reads
What is the Meaning of Life?
The latest online issue of Southern Cross Review includes 2 lectures by Rudolf Steiner on The Meaning of Life.
- John Ralph's journal
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
- 465 reads
Threefold Conversation
A contribution of thoughts about conversation and society. This was prompted by a comparison of conversation with the economic life and specifically thinking of conversation as a kind of flow of currency.
- Tim Bourke's journal
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 485 reads
What is an Anthroposophist? Traditional or Progressive?
Working with a broad definition of an anthroposophist I have found the Traditional anthroposophist who is more concerned with the traditions of the Anthroposophical Society as an institution and Progressive anthroposophists who are more concerned with anthroposophy today and how it relates to the present world.
- Tom Last's journal
- 10 comments
- Read more
- 678 reads
Anthroposophy and eurythmy
Steiner is often quoted as saying that eurythmy is a child of anthroposophy. What are the implications of this idea today?
- John Ralph's journal
- 30 comments
- Read more
- 1354 reads
What is an Anthroposophist?
I have been reading on the site lately some attempts at providing a definition of the term 'anthroposophist'.
- Jay Harms's journal
- 30 comments
- Read more
- 1096 reads



Is self-knowledge about our true self --beyond the experience of our self in ordinary everyday life-- possible?
Ubuntu (pronounced "oo-BOON-too") is a traditional African idea that means rather more than humanity toward others and I am because you are also the belief in a universal bond of sharing that connects all humanity.
Today I was asked to contribute to a conversation in a couple of weeks on the theme How can anthroposophy be effectively communicated to non-anthroposophists?